Pole and frame tents are great for events, home, or camping. Choosing between these two tents can be confusing. If you are looking for the best tent, there are a few things to consider.
For example, pole tents are cheaper and easier to set up but not as stable in windy conditions. In contrast, frame tents are more costly but durable and offer more stability in windy conditions. There is much more to consider when choosing a pole tent vs frame tent.
What Is a Pole Tent?
Pole tents are the most traditional type of tent. It’s easy to understand why this tent style is popular, considering they are simple, elegant, and customized with various side walls. There are two main pole tents: the standard tent and the high-peak tent. Whichever tent style you buy, consider its features like waterproofing rating, size, durability, etc.; and tent accessories.
Features of a Pole Tent
One of the characteristic features of a pole tent is that it features at least one central pole. This pole serves as the primary structural support. And if the pole tent is large, it will come with several central poles. Without this additional anchor, the tent poles wouldn’t anchor safely. You will need other support to support the canopy’s weight.
The pole tent’s stability depends on how well it is stacked into the ground. So, dry ground is needed to secure the anchors. This means it’s best to use a pole tent on concrete or paved surfaces such as sidewalks, parking lots, etc. If the weather forecast is windy or rainy, and you have the pole tent on the soil, note that soggy soil is not conducive for secure staking.
In terms of appearance, a traditional pole tent has a distinctive peaked appearance because of the center pole. As such, it is an excellent tent for formal events. Also, the center pole makes a great location to attach string lights, flowers, and other creative things to spice up the event. You can find a good number of pole tents at Roofnest.
Pros
- Budget-friendly
- Quick and easy to set up on asphalt and grass
- Distinct canopy appearance
- Large in size
Cons
- Requires more space for anchoring
What Is a Frame Tent?
Frame tents are also called high-peak or west coast, depending on the style. The primary difference between pole and frame tent is that frame tents are not staked into the ground or feature center poles. As such, frame tents are ideal for nearly every occasion because of the ease of adapting to most settings.
Features of Frame Tent
Without a center pole to support the weight of the canopy, a frame tent relies on vertical poles around the tent’s perimeter. In essence, the frame is the tent’s support system. But when assembled properly, a frame tent is sturdy, stylish, and reliable.
Setting up a frame tent is similar to a camping or backpack tent, but with a few variations. You will need a few helpers and a sledgehammer to set up a frame tent. Begin fitting all the poles with the center crown first.
One of the benefits of using a frame tent as opposed to a pole tent is that it maximizes your space. And because frame tents do not rely on the surface beneath for support, they are an excellent option for long-term usage. When staking isn’t possible, you can hold a frame tent in place with concrete ballast or water barrels.
Unlike pole tents, frame tents are not as glamorous, but they are still an excellent choice for special events and businesses. It lacks that dramatic exterior look, as frame tents are ideal for interior spaces. The design of frame tents has a more geometric shape.
As such, frame tents are terrific for a tented wedding reception, poolside gatherings, or other outdoor event. Whatever the case, frame tents provide you with plenty of unobstructed floor space. And if you are searching for the perfect frame tent, Snow Peak features a good number of tents you can use.
Pros
- Freestanding
- Flexible layout/floor plan options
- Aesthetically appealing
- More room inside with no obstructions thanks to its no center poles design
Cons
- Requires additional parts and hardware, making setup a bit more complex
Pole Tent vs Frame Tent: Which Is Better For You?
It’s easy to decide between getting a pole tent and a frame tent when you ask the right question. Below are some primary features that can help you design which of these two tents is better for you.
Location of the Tent
Where you want to place the tent is the first question you should consider when choosing a tent. A pole tent is better if you need one covering plenty of grass space. But a frame tent is a better option when the space is limited, and you need to place it on a hard surface.
Type of Event
A pole tent is an excellent choice if you need a tent for short-term events like weddings and parties. Pole tents are easier to set up and transport, making them great for short-term events. But for long-term events like a business stand or waiting spot, go for frame tents; they are sturdier.
Available Space
Always consider the layout, available floor space and interior space, and the area where you will set the tent up before deciding which tent style to get. If you have limited space, and want to shade a small area for camping or your outdoor event, go for a frame tent. Frame tents are freestanding tents that are not dependent on anchor ropes and tension for support. On the other hand, if you want a tent to cover an ample space, say as much as 200 square feet, then a traditional pole tent is best.
Budget
Budget is another crucial factor to consider when deciding which tent to get. Pole tents are cheaper than frame tents. Although the cost of these two tents is not a vast difference, if every penny counts, it may impact your decision.
Setup Complexity
The complexity of setting up these two tents is different. The pole tent is often easier to set up. With the right parts available, you can have it up and functioning in no time. But the frame tent is more complex to set it. It takes a lot longer due to more parts. So, you will need more people to set up the frame tent.
Aesthetics
Finally, if aesthetics matters to you, the pole tent is best for you as it creates an exotic ambiance. Its high ceiling interior and external aesthetics make the shade of pole tents look spacious and luxurious. But frame tents are less aesthetically appealing than its counterpart.
Conclusion
Choosing a pole tent over a frame tent may seem daunting at first. But with the correct information, making a choice suitable for your needs is much easier. Frame tents are more versatile, making them great for commercial use than pole tents.
However, pole tents remain the most popular option because they are more aesthetically appealing, making them great for all occasions. So, always consider both tents’ benefits and potential drawbacks when deciding. Remember, every situation is different, so make your decision based on the case.
